We Should Immediately Nationalize SpaceX and Starlink
-
They landed people on the moon and then did fuck all for decades.
When Musk started SpaceX he was not well known yet, SpaceX came before Tesla.
He was able to get into the businesses he has because he was rich yes, but you can find many accounts of engineers that worked under him speak of how good he was at finding ways to cut unnecessary costs.
He’s not a technical genius that’s for sure. But he has been a good CEO for SpaceX. Terrible one for Tesla though, mostly because he bought into his own myth and became a drug addict. But I refuse to simply wave away his achievements simply because I don’t like him. I can not like someone and still acknowledge they have done something good.
schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 12:16 zuletzt editiert von senal@programming.dev 6. Juli 2025, 15:08They landed people on the moon and then did fuck all for decades.
Indeed, all i was saying is that they were capable given budget and circumstances.
That budget and direction comes from the government.
When Musk started SpaceX he was not well known yet, SpaceX came before Tesla.
I will admit, i thought spacex was just another company he bought his way in to, like tesla, seems i was mistaken about that.
He was able to get into the businesses he has because he was rich yes, but you can find many accounts of engineers that worked under him speak of how good he was at finding ways to cut unnecessary costs.
And you can equally find many accounts of having to distract him from the day to day operations because he's unreliable , unpredictable and chaotic (none of those meant in a good way).
He's also known for buying good press and using litigation to silence people.
He’s not a technical genius that’s for sure. But he has been a good CEO for SpaceX.
I doubt this, but that could just be bias, i don't have any actual evidence of the long term impact of him as CEO.
Recently though, he's provably been significantly more of a liability than a benefit, even if just from a PR and public sentiment point of view.
But I refuse to simply wave away his achievements simply because I don’t like him. I can not like someone and still acknowledge they have done something good.
Indeed, i push back on the myth that he's some self made tony stark genius, but it isn't like he's not achieved anything.
I would personally attribute most of that to neptoism, wealth, luck and opportunity, but that doesn't remove the achievement itself.
-
Quite ironic from people constantly accusing their political adversaries to be communists...
schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 12:16 zuletzt editiert vonWell that's not really the case. Conservatives will accuse progressive of being communists, and claim any social services are examples of communism. But it's mostly those progressives here on Lemmy suggesting communist ideas.
So it's not really ironic, just unsurprising I guess.
-
Tax burdens for billionaires
schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 12:18 zuletzt editiert vonAlso losses. Gotta get that sweet, sweet too-big-to-fail bailout money.
-
I didn't realize how temporary and disposable Starlink's satellites were. They incinerate 4 or 5 a day by de-orbiting them into the ozone. Here's a pretty good CNET article that talks about how they “dispose” of them. IDK, doesn't seem sustainable. They also mention the bandwidth gains are being diminished with the influx of new users, so their solution is more temporary satellites.
schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 12:25 zuletzt editiert vonYeah, if they want to make satellites last longer, they could go a bit higher in their orbits. The option is there.
-
This post did not contain any content.schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 12:26 zuletzt editiert von reksas@sopuli.xyz 6. Juli 2025, 14:28
Just having such wealth and thus power in hands of singular humans is risk to all of humanity. With musk you are but big enough drug fueled temper tantrum away from pretty important infrastructure coming crashing down.
-
You guys are so stuck in the cult of personality. WE PAID FOR EVERYTHING SPACEX DID. IT BELONGS TO US.
schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 12:30 zuletzt editiert von cocodapuf@lemmy.world 6. Juli 2025, 14:51Let's say I bought you a car, I paid for it in full and then gave it to you, and in return you sometimes drive me around.
Let's say I get tired of this arrangement, should I repossess the car just to drive it into the ocean? What would be the point of that? Sure, it's rightfully mine, but what good does it do to destroy it?
"IT BELONGS TO US" is not a very compelling argument for arbitrary distribution.
-
Of course he was always a jerk, but I still think of a reality where Elon never went (officially) Nazi and just stuck with his otherwise important companies. Tesla being an important early mover in EVs, especially in such an oil-dependent country, and all the cool stuff SpaceX has been up to.
schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 12:32 zuletzt editiert vonI hear you, why can't we be in that timeline?
-
This post did not contain any content.schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 12:54 zuletzt editiert von
Do that, so that when the US Gov. falls SpaceX and Starlink does too.
-
It's also frustrating that people keep saying SpaceX "relies on taxpayer money" as if we're just giving them money for no reason. It's all contracts! SpaceX only gets money for providing some kind of service. They're not being bailed out or anything. The Musk hate is justified but so misdirected.
schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 13:00 zuletzt editiert vonThis really is just the dumbest thread on Lemmy right now. A bunch of reactionary mob think. "Grab your torches and pitchforks, let's burn it all down!"
-
NASA is clearly capable of things given the right circumstances and budget.
Absolutely agree with this but there is no denying the innovation levels at spacex are higher (I'm not saying this is down to musk specifically. The man is a horror story of a human).
We were all in total awe when seeing booster stages land themselves successfully for the first time. It was such a giant leap forward and to the best of my knowledge no government funded space agency was even considering it before spacex.
schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 13:06 zuletzt editiert vonAbsolutely agree with this but there is no denying the innovation levels at spacex are higher
Undeniably, they've been doing amazing work (at least from my rocketry technology peasant point of view).
-
Has US nationalized anything this millenia? I really don't see that ever happening
schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 13:08 zuletzt editiert vonAirport security was nationalized as the TSA. Aside from that no.
-
Lets reach a compromise. Impeach Trump (successfully) and then take away SpaceX from Elon. That way things would be fair.
schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 13:08 zuletzt editiert vonI honestly don't care about Elon, just get Trump out.
-
Has US nationalized anything this millenia? I really don't see that ever happening
schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 13:09 zuletzt editiert vonTechnically the auto industry in 2008.
-
Lets reach a compromise. Impeach Trump (successfully) and then take away SpaceX from Elon. That way things would be fair.
schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 13:26 zuletzt editiert vonTrump has been impeached successfully. Twice. What I assume you mean is that he hasn't been removed from office. That could be the consequence of an impeachment, but not necessarily.
-
I would suggest that maybe you should leave SpaceX alone, if you want to still have a space program.
Maybe think about to nationalize healthcare insurance, it seems to be something more usefull
schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 13:31 zuletzt editiert vonYeah, let's leave all that power in the hands of one narcissistic egomaniac who's frequently going on ketamine benders. What could possibly go wrong?
-
This post did not contain any content.schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 13:32 zuletzt editiert von
Pedo-nation
-
This really is just the dumbest thread on Lemmy right now. A bunch of reactionary mob think. "Grab your torches and pitchforks, let's burn it all down!"
schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 13:34 zuletzt editiert vonI've got the feeling none of y'all read past the headline.
-
I fully agree. Any industry that can’t survive on its own and needs public funds, shouldn’t exist. If it’s an essential service it should be nationalized.
schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 13:36 zuletzt editiert vonSo you want Donald Trump in charge of the telecom industry and any other industries that have received some sort of public subsidy?
-
I honestly don't care about Elon, just get Trump out.
schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 13:45 zuletzt editiert von aa5b@lemmy.world 6. Juli 2025, 15:49For whatever reasons Musk has found himself as ceo of some wildly successful visionary companies. It has not changed that they are finally bringing the future to the present, disrupting old technologies in favor of newer and better, for a better world. And the musk from before his breakdown deserves a lot of credit.
At this point I no longer care about musk either, but SpaceX and Tesla are critical. Or at least SpaceX is. Tesla has not yet finished disrupting vehicle manufacturing , but if we’re content to let Chinese companies go ahead, they’re ready and willing. Legacy manufacturers have been slapped up the side of the face, but if they’re still not awake at this point it’s on them
-
For whatever reasons Musk has found himself as ceo of some wildly successful visionary companies. It has not changed that they are finally bringing the future to the present, disrupting old technologies in favor of newer and better, for a better world. And the musk from before his breakdown deserves a lot of credit.
At this point I no longer care about musk either, but SpaceX and Tesla are critical. Or at least SpaceX is. Tesla has not yet finished disrupting vehicle manufacturing , but if we’re content to let Chinese companies go ahead, they’re ready and willing. Legacy manufacturers have been slapped up the side of the face, but if they’re still not awake at this point it’s on them
schrieb am 7. Juni 2025, 13:49 zuletzt editiert vonI’m sorry, but credit for what? For being born privileged and buying talent? If you can’t beat ‘em, buy ‘em, right?
Yeah, I guess he deserves praise for being a good liar and basically selling pipe dreams?
-
Zuckerberg: AI increased the time spent on Facebook and Instagram in Q2 | TechCrunch
Technology496 vor 10 Tagenvor 10 Tagen1
-
-
OpenAI signs deal with United Kingdom to find government uses for its models
Technology496 vor 22 Tagenvor 22 Tagen1
-
-
-
AI learns math reasoning by playing Snake and Tetris-like games rather than using math datasets
Technology 22. Juni 2025, 15:271
-
-