Mozilla warns Germany could soon declare ad blockers illegal
-
cross-posted from: https://lemmy.ml/post/34873574
This is grounded in the assertion that a website’s HTML/CSS is a protected computer program that an ad blocker intervenes in the in-memory execution structures (DOM, CSSOM, rendering tree), this constituting unlawful reproduction and modification.
Dumbest fucking thing I've ever heard of.
Will they make Reader More in browsers illegal, too?
What about "dark mode" or "resize font" when the website doesn't offer those accessibility features?
Will they make the "mute" function on browser tabs illegal, since it modifies the website author's intention to olay audio upon page load?
I will continue to block ads, spyware, trackers, unwanted elements, popups, and social media links, "illegal" or not.
-
I know I'm gonna get a lot of hate for this because everyone here despises ads, but I can see an argument for it. I don't know if it is legaly sound, but morally, it boils down to the fact that you are literally using a service without paying for it. The website is offering you a product and the payment is ads. If you don't want to pay for it, don't use it, otherwise you really are just stealing it (even if that "stealing" costs very little to the site). I personally use an adblocker and agree that ads on most sites are obnoxious, but I also feel like people make adblockers out to be completely black and white, which they are not.
'using a service without paying for it' alright. do you want us to sign contractual agreements before visiting websites? Most companies want people to use mobile apps these days because of the legal implications of editing those apps. The ads are baked in.
it comes down to the philosophy of internet systems you ascribe to.
I'd like to see your reaction to that television patent that forces people to stand up and clap after the advertisement.
I'd like to see your reaction to me placing sticky notes on my physical screen over the advertisement's location such that I never perceive the content.
I'd like to see you kneel, subordinate human worker. Do my bidding. Watch my ads. It's the moral thing to do.